7 Lessons in Running a Successful Restaurant Company from Cameron Mitchell

7 Lessons in running a successful restaurant company from Cameron Mitchell

7 Lessons in Running a Successful Restaurant Company from Cameron Mitchell

Cameron Mitchell Restaurants, the group known for wide-reaching brands such as Ocean Prime, Marcella’s, and Molly Woo’s, has been an industry leader for decades. At the helm of the company is Cameron Mitchell himself, who has worked in restaurants since he was 16 years old. 

In addition to working his way up from dishwasher to founder and president of a restaurant company, Cameron has been honored by Nation’s Restaurant News and the U.S. Small Business Administration, among other organizations, and he also served as Chairman and Board of Trustees at the Culinary Institute of America (the first alumnus to do so).

Success in the restaurant business doesn’t come easily, so when we see someone at Cameron’s level, we all take note. Recently, we asked him all about his background and philosophy to learn his top insights for growing and thriving in this ever-changing industry. Read on for inspiration, education, and much more.

1. Set specific goals

After graduating high school, Cameron was working in restaurants—washing dishes, bussing tables, and cooking here and there. He didn’t immediately enroll in college because he didn’t know what he wanted to do. “I was living at home, working two jobs, going nowhere,” he says. He was suspended for three days for being late and put on probation, during which time he worked a double-shift as an AM grill cook and a host in the evening. That night, before service, he looked across the kitchen and said, “This is what I’m going to do the rest of my life—I absolutely love this.”

After his shift, he went home and wrote out his goals: to graduate from the Culinary Institute of America; become Executive Chef by the time he was 23; become a GM by 24; a Regional Director by 26; a VP of Operations by 30; and president of a restaurant company by 35. He woke his mom up at 1 a.m. to share the goals with her.

“I went back to work the next day and literally did a 180-degree turn,” says Cameron. “On Friday I was working for the man, for beer money, lost and lazy, and Saturday morning I was working for myself, my career, my future. I was the hardest working guy in the kitchen. I really never looked back from there. It changed for me overnight in one fell swoop.”

And the reality? He beat many of those initial goals he set, ultimately overseeing the operations for four restaurants by the time he was 26. In 1992, he decided to start his own restaurant company and began raising the capital and building the business plan for his first concept. The following year, in 1993, Cameron’s opened its doors in Columbus, Ohio.

2. Start with culture and values

Many people dream of opening their own restaurant; Cameron dreamed of running a restaurant company. “I wanted the company to be around for 100 years, long after me—I didn’t want it to be about me, I wanted it to be about our values and culture, whether I’m there or not.”

In the first few weeks after starting his own company, Cameron wrote out those values. He aimed to create a company that was people-focused. “I knew that would be a true differentiator because it wasn’t going on out there.” Even today, Cameron Mitchell Restaurants’ culture is based on the answers to these five basic questions:

  • Who are we? We’re great people delivering genuine hospitality.
  • What do we want to be? We want to be an extraordinary restaurant company. By definition, that’s the opposite of ordinary. 
  • What is our mission? Our mission is to thrive with both cultural and fiscal responsibility. You’d think that as CEO of a restaurant company, my number one goal is to make a profit. That’s not true. Our number one goal is to maintain our culture and values. That, to me, is the key to long-term profitability and viability. 
  • What is your role? We have 4,000 associates, lots of different job descriptions, restaurants all over the country—but all 4,000 of us have the exact same role in the company. And that is to make raving fans of five groups of people we do business with: our fellow associates, our guests, our communities, our partners, and our purveyors. 

Finally, what is our goal? We have hundreds of business goals; they change and come and go. One goal stays the same, and that’s to be better today than we were yesterday, and be better tomorrow than we were today. It creates a culture of change in our organization. That also becomes our insurance policy—we’ve grown every year.

3. Put your associates first

In addition to the culture, Cameron stands firmly by this core value: associates come first.

“You’d think the guest comes first, but I don’t believe that,” he says. “I would take that a step further and say that I don’t think we have a direct relationship with our guests; we have a direct relationship with our people. It’s not that I don’t care about great guest service—I love to take care of people. But I believe the true path to great guest service is by taking care of our people. We take care of our people, our people take care of our guests, and our guests take care of our company. When our people know how much we care about them, they, in turn, will take care of us and care about our guest experience. And ultimately that leads to continued growth in sales and profitability.”

4. Make a milkshake toast

One day Cameron went with his family to a restaurant and ordered his son a grilled cheese and a chocolate milkshake. The server told him they couldn’t make either. He ordered a club sandwich—hold the ham, turkey, bacon, etc.—and asked to have what was left sautéed in a pan. Then, he ordered chocolate milk with a side of “a la mode” and asked her to have the kitchen whip it up in a blender. She agreed, a bit reluctantly.

The whole experience left an impression, and Cameron shared the story a couple of weeks later while delivering a keynote speech at an event held by a local business magazine. “I’m talking about our company, and I tell that story and how it wouldn’t happen in our organization,” he says. Soon after, one of the event attendees stopped him on the street and said she had tried to order a chocolate milkshake at Mitchell’s Fish Market (a CMR restaurant) and the team wouldn’t make it for her. “It was like she punched me in the gut right there in the street. I got all fired up for the Monday morning exec meeting. I said, ‘We’ve got a problem here—our culture isn’t permeating the organization.”

Today, every time a new associate goes through orientation during their first day with the company, the team tells the story of the milkshake—and actually makes a milkshake for the new employee. They start all major meetings and leadership conferences with milkshake toasts. “We make thousands of chocolate milkshakes a year to drive that point home.”

Ultimately, it’s about attitude, Cameron says. “We have a pervasive attitude in our company that we can do what we will. The number one question I get all the time is: where do you get such great people? I say, ‘We hire the same people everyone else does. The difference is, we treat them great.’”

7 Lessons in Running a Successful Restaurant Company from Cameron Mitchell

5. Scale the culture, scale the concept

“The first restaurant I opened, I was scared to death,” says Cameron. By 2000, he had 10 restaurants in Columbus and was starting to think about opening out of town. That was challenging at first, but as the company continued to scale the team gained more and more confidence. Today, CMR has opened concepts from coast to coast, making mistakes and adjustments along the way. 

“In the beginning, we opened restaurants with outside-hire managers, and all of a sudden the culture and values were not there the way it should be,” he says. “We typically now open a restaurant with a minimum of five managers on staff from within the company so we can inculcate that culture in the new market. Today, our culture and values out of town are the same as they are in town.”

Additionally, just because a brand is successful in Columbus, Ohio doesn’t necessarily mean it’s going to work everywhere else. The team has had to evolve brands, which take years to hone and get right. “You’re always tinkering,” says Cameron. With great people, systems, and processes in place, the road to growth gets much smoother.

6. Bridge the front and back of house

Cameron is unusual as an owner/operator because he’s worked both sides of the business: the kitchen and the dining room. “You’re either a famous chef or you’re Danny Meyer,” he says. He knows how chefs can yell and scream because he’s been there. He’s seen how angry, condescending words can make servers too scared to go into the kitchen and ask questions. “It’s just a waste of time, and we don’t tolerate it.”

At CMR everyone has to speak to one another with respect—even chefs. “That’s how you run a great business. You can’t have one side of your business reacting negatively to the other—I learned over the years that’s not good.”

Another bonus of his varied background is the inspiration Cameron brings to the employees in the back of the house especially. The kitchen staff know he used to be an Executive Chef, a line cook, and a dishwasher. “They love that,” he says. “I wouldn’t trade it. You’ve got to have a certain mix of personality and character to do both.”

7. Figure out how to make it work

It’s no secret that the industry is in the midst of huge change, with minimum wage hikes and rising costs across the board. How does a veteran like Cameron think about business challenges? “You either sit down and wring your hands about it, or you can move forward and press on with a positive mental attitude. My glass is half full because I’ve got a pitcher of water sitting beside it—that’s how I look at life.”

Cameron is in favor of the wage hikes, which he says are good for his people. Plus, if everyone in the industry is experiencing them, there’s a level, competitive playing field. But at the end of the day, he says, it’s just another business challenge—and business is always difficult. “Any business has got their challenges—you’ve got to know how to work them.”

CMR continues to build the Ocean Prime brand across the country. In recent years, they’ve overhauled the more casual Rusty Bucket brand. They plan to continue the specialty brands they’ve launched in Columbus, as well as their catering business. With so many years of success behind him, Cameron is starting to think about his legacy and eventual retirement, transitioning into a steward of the company versus “going full-throttle.”

“I use the snowball analogy: you keep rolling and rolling and it gets bigger and bigger. That’s what you have to do” he says. With 40 years of experience in the restaurant business behind him, he’s trying to make a transition. “I call it the fourth quarter of my career.”


10 things you need to know before starting a restaurant remodel

10 things you need to know before starting a restaurant remodel

If your restaurant has been open for 10 years and business is good, that’s something to celebrate. But at some...
Olivia Terenzio
How to Raise Funds for Your Restaurant

How to Raise Funds for Your Restaurant

Few aspiring restaurateurs have the cash on hand to get their dream off the ground. That’s where investors come in....
Alison Arth
Hospitality in real life: How to make every guest feel like a VIP

Hospitality in real life: How to make every guest feel like a VIP

We all know that hospitality is the key to success in the restaurant industry—not just getting butts in seats, but...
Olivia Terenzio
Q&A's See all
How The Anchovy Bar creates unique experiences through chef, brewery, and winery collaborations

How The Anchovy Bar creates unique experiences through chef, brewery, and winery collaborations

Born from the team behind State Bird Provisions and The Progress, The Anchovy Bar stands out for its focus on...
Joy Manning
How Uni Restaurant in Boston is stepping into the future with OpenTable

How Uni Restaurant in Boston is stepping into the future with OpenTable

With varying degrees of caution, people have returned to restaurants. Many vaccinated diners feel more at ease meeting for dinner...
Joy Manning